Trump arrives in courtroom
Donald Trump has entered the courtroom.
His suit is navy and his satiny tie is marigold-toned â a step away from his normal blue-on-blue or blue-and-red attire.
Key events
Chris Conroy is now referring to Donald Trumpâs recent comments on Michael Cohen, his one-time consigliere-turned-star prosecution witness.
âMichael Cohen is not a political opponent, defendantâs comments about Michael Cohen relate to issues at the heart of the proceeding,â he said, adding, âDefendant is doing everything he can to make this case about his politics â itâs not itâs about his criminal conduct.â
Conroy said they are asking for financial penalties again. âTo minimise disruptions to this proceeding, we are not yet seeking jail,â he said.
Prosecutor Christopher Conroy is now moving on to the second alleged violation â Donald Trumpâs comments about David Pecker outside court.
âThe defendant knows what heâs doing, He talks about the testifying witness, says nice things, in front of the cameras,â Conroy said.
He argued that this is intentional â not Trump just blathering in response to a barrage of reportersâ questions.
âHe selectively responded to this question and not others,â Conroy argued, noting that even though his comments on Pecker were positive, they are nonetheless âdeliberate shots across the bow [for] anyone who comes to this courtroom to talk about the defendant and what he did.â
The prosecution started off by pointing to judge Juan Merchanâs order.
âThe order was issued because of the defendantâs persistent and escalating rhetoric aimed at participants in this hearing⦠Heâs already been found by the court to have violated the order nine times and has done it again here,â prosecutor Christopher Conroy said of Donald Trump.
âHe was on the media and he used that platform there to criticized the seated jury in the case,â he said.
âBy talking about the jury at all, he places this process and this proceeding here in jeopardy â this is what the order forbids, and he did it anyway,â Conroy continued.
Court has started for the day.
âI looked at the exhibits that were provided by both the people and the defense,â judge Juan Merchan says of the prosecutionâs most recent push for contempt.
He is now asking prosecutors to go through each of the alleged violations.
Prior to heading inside the courtroom, Donald Trump stopped and addressed the press.
He bragged about his rallies in Wisconsin and Michigan, saying, âWe had tremendous rallies, sold-out rallies that were packed and the enthusiasmâs never been better.â
Trump also spoke about inflation, saying, âInterest rates are obviously not going to be able to be reduced prior to the election because inflation is roaring back.â
He went on to praise the police crackdowns on the Palestinian solidarity student encampments at UCLA and Columbia and blamed the âradical left lunatics.â
âThe right is not your problem, despite what law enforcement likes to say,â he added.
Weâre still waiting for proceedings to kick off.
As Donald Trump and Todd Blanche, his defense lawyer, are chatting at the table, the ex-president appears to be more animated, more engaged, than he has generally been.
As Donald Trump walked down the aisle to the defense table, he looked around at the gallery.
His expression hadnât changed much since his last appearance in court.
Trump arrives in courtroom
Donald Trump has entered the courtroom.
His suit is navy and his satiny tie is marigold-toned â a step away from his normal blue-on-blue or blue-and-red attire.
Donald Trumpâs motorcade has arrived at the courthouse, according to pool reports.
Here are some images coming through the newswires:
Earlier this week Trump was fined $9,000 for violating a gag order imposed by Juan Merchan, the trial judge. And on Thursday, prosecutors will seek another $4,000 fine for four more alleged violations.
Merchan said on Tuesday that he might jail Trump if he continues to defy the gag order, saying the fines allowed by New York law â $1,000 per violation â might not be enough to serve as a deterrent for someone of Trumpâs wealth.
The gag order aims to prevent the former president from intimidating witnesses, jurors and other participants in his first criminal trial. It does not prevent Trump from criticizing prosecutors or the judge himself.
Trump says the gag order restricts his free-speech rights and prevents him from responding to political attacks. Merchan will consider whether Trump violated the gag order on four separate occasions last week, by referring to Michael Cohen as a âliarâ and to David Pecker, the former National Enquirer publisher and another witness, as a ânice guyâ in statements to news media.
Prosecutors say Trump also violated the gag order by saying in a television interview that âthat jury was picked so fast â 95% Democrats. The areaâs mostly all Democrat.â
The Guardianâs David Smith was on the campaign trail with Trump and reports the former president ran through his familiar litany of falsehoods and complaints.
David has this dispatch:
At a remote rural airport in Michigan, an outsized plane touched down as music from Tom Cruiseâs film Top Gun boomed from loudspeakers. Late afternoon sunshine gleamed off five giant golden letters on the planeâs side â âTRUMPâ â and its Rolls Royce engines. A crowd bedecked in red roared as the plane rolled to a standstill behind a blue âTRUMPâ lectern.
A door opened and men in dark glasses and dark suits from what Donald Trump would call âcentral castingâ made their way down the stairs. âTrump! Trump!â the audience chanted, raising hundreds of camera phones in eager anticipation. Great Balls of Fire, Macho Man and YMCA blared. Finally, the former and would-be future president emerged, clapping and fist pumping to the sound of whoops and cheers and Lee Greenwoodâs God Bless the USA.
How different the warm embrace from Trumpâs recent experience as a defendant on criminal trial in a chilly, dingy courtroom in New York. On those days, threatened with prison, he looks old, vulnerable and small. Back on the election campaign trail, it is all about hypermasculine energy and bigness â big plane, big crowds, big promises and big lies.
During his brief break from court, Trump returned to the campaign trail on Wednesday â and used a campaign stop to repeat his attacks on the trial judge as âcrookedâ.
The AP writes:
Trumpâs remarks at events in the battleground states of Wisconsin and Michigan were being closely watched after he received a $9,000 fine for making public statements about people connected to the criminal case.
âThere is no crime. I have a crooked judge. Heâs a totally conflicted judge,â Trump claimed as he spoke to supporters at an event in Waukesha, Wisconsin, claiming again that this and other cases against him are led by the White House to undermine his campaign.
Later at a rally in Freeland, Michigan, he said he was being forced to spend days in a âkangaroo court roomâ, and claimed without evidence the district attorney was taking orders from the Biden administration.
Hugo Lowell
Donald Trump was confronted with the details of how the former lawyer for Stormy Daniels, the adult film actor, secured the $130,000 in hush money at the heart of his criminal trial in New York, after being found to be in criminal contempt of a gag order prohibiting attacks on witnesses.
The direct examination of the lawyer, Keith Davidson, is expected to continue on Thursday when the trial resumes. Here are the key takeaways from day nine of the trial, People of the State of New York v Donald J Trump:
Trump trial to hear further testimony from Stormy Daniels lawyer Keith Davidson
Donald Trumpâs hush-money trial will pick up again today after the trial took a break on Wednesday â and jurors are due to hear again from the lawyer who negotiated deals on behalf of two women alleged to have had affairs with the former US president.
Keith Davidson has already given colorful testimony about how deals to pay Karen McDougal and Stormy Daniels came together in 2016. Prosecutors are using his testimony to help jurors understand the mechanics of Trumpâs efforts to pay off women and convince jurors that it was done in service of his campaign.
The judge in the case, Juan Merchan, will also hold a hearing on four more instances where Trump is alleged to have violated the gag order that bars him from attacking a number of people linked to the trial. Merchan has already fined Trump $9,000 for nine violations of the order.
Hereâs a quick recap of what happened in court on Tuesday:
-
Davidson testified that he began representing McDougal in 2016 âto provide advice and counsel ⦠regarding a personal interaction that she hadâ with Trump. Davidson reached out to Dylan Howard, the editor of the National Enquirer, promising a âblockbuster Trump storyâ. Howard replied by text message: âI will get you more than ANYONE for it. You know why.â
-
Davidson was questioned by prosecutors about texts in which he was asked whether Trump had cheated on his wife. In those texts, Howard asked Davidson: âDid he cheat on Melania?â ââI really cannot say yet, sorry,ââ Davidson said, reading his text to Howard aloud.
-
Davidson testified that the leak of Trumpâs Access Hollywood tape had âtremendous influenceâ on the interest in Stormy Danielsâs story. He said that Danielsâs agent, Gina Rodriguez, had reached a deal with Howard for the tabloid to acquire the rights to her story for $120,000, but Howard backed out of the deal.
-
Howard told Rodriguez to call Cohen and complete the deal directly with him, but she refused to negotiate with him following a previous interaction after which she described Cohen as a âjerkâ and âvery, very aggressiveâ. Rodriguez asked Davidson to step in and negotiate the deal with Cohen, he testified.
-
Davidson said he used a pair of pseudonyms: Stormy Daniels became Peggy Peterson; Donald Trump became David Dennison.
-
Davidson testified that the payment to Daniels did not come even after both parties had reached a deal. Cohen made a series of excuses for the delay, Davidson said, noting that he âthought he was trying to kick the can down the round until after the electionâ.
-
Davidson was asked if Cohen ever told him whom he was representing in the Daniels negotiations. He said the implication was clear and that Cohen âleaned on his close affiliation with Donald Trump ⦠He let me know it at every opportunity he could that he was working for Donald Trump.â
Court is expected to resume at 9.30am ET. Weâll bring you the latest updates from the Manhattan courthouse as we get them.